Problem 4: Why do people believe different things, and why are they so certain that their view of the world is correct, and others are wrong?
Essay Assignment: Hunger and Sex
One of the central ideas in the
anthropological study of belief and religion has to do with how values, beliefs,
and religious convictions are expressed. We will examine in class various
examples of ceremony and ritual, and, most importantly, the role of metaphor in
the construction and representation of belief. One society that we will examine
is the Kwakiutl of British Colombia. The Kwakiult, as you’ll learn, place great
emphasis on the metaphor of “eating” or “hunger.” Much of their experience is
interpreted through this natural act, and represented in their ceremony. Some
have suggested that Americans, also, interpret and express much of their
experience through a natural act, that of sexual intercourse. That is, much of
our language, art, and the like, specifically apply sexual metaphors to other
aspects of our lives. Your task in this essay is to compare the way that the
Kwakiutl apply the metaphor of eating or hunger to the way that Americans apply
the metaphor of sexuality or sexual desire. You will need to answer the
following questions:
1. What are some of the symbols of sexuality used in advertising? That is, how is sex represented?
2. The Kwakiutl represent eating as something to be controlled. How is that the same or different from how sexuality is represented in commercials?
3. Metaphors of eating or sexuality must also be "acted out" in the form of ritual or myth. How is sexuality "acted out" in commercials?
4. How are the metaphors of sexuality related to metaphors of love in the United States?
You will need to incorporate the readings and discussions on ritual and ceremony and their role in the creation and maintenance of belief.
|
Date |
Question |
Readings |
|
3/7
|
Question 4.1 How does language affect the meanings people assign to experience? |
Text, Chapter 4, Intro. and Question. 4.1; C&C, The Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis: Worlds Shaped by Words, p. 63 SECOND PAPER IS DUE |
|
Question 4.2 How does symbolic action reinforce a particular view of the world? |
Text, Question. 4.2; C&C, Taraka’s Ghost, p. 299 |
|
|
3/21 |
Question 4.3 How do people come to believe what they do, and how do they continue to hold to their beliefs even they seem contradictory or ambiguous? |
Text, Question. 4.3; C&C, A Woman’s Curse, p. 240 |
|
Question 4.4: How does the way we live affect our beliefs and rituals? |
Text, Question. 4.4; C&C, Baseball Rituals, p. 306; Run for the Wall, p. 316 |
|
|
Question 4.5 How can people reorder their view of the world if it becomes unsatisfactory? |
Text, Question 4.5 and CS #4; C&C, Cargo Beliefs and Religious Experiences, p. 330; Men’s Pleasure, Women’s Labor; Tourism for Sex, p. 355 |